Fat Olives Restaurant

Reviews

• Lisa Y.

  star star star star star 5 September 2026

  Visiting Homer July 4 weekend. Everything is packed. So lucky to walk in with a short wait here. Believe the ratings. They're delicious. Super friendly service (thanks Danielle aka Nancy). They were hoppin and the staff was on top of it with smiles.
  
  Everything that passed us looked delicious. I got pasta with meatballs. They were a little crispy on one side but pretty good still. Sauce had a little kick to it. I don't like spice so it may have just been me.
  
  My friend got seafood bowl with salmon, halibut, and shrimp. She loved it!!!
  
  What a treat!!!

• Katrina G.

  star star star star star 4 September 2026

  We went here for lunch today and had a great experience! They had a lot of different options for lunch. We decided to get slices of pizza. They were only $4.50 each. We got 2 pieces of pepperoni and one slice of a veggie pizza. The total bill was only around $14, which is a pretty good price for the size of the slices of pizza. The pizza was delicious!
  
  It was also cool to watch the employees hand toss the pizzas and the place had a relaxing ambiance. The staff was really friendly and we really enjoyed our meal.

• Onaona K.

  star star star star star 3 September 2026

  We found this place via yelp. This place is very popular and it was busy, so we decided to do take out.
  
  We ordered multiple things for two people, because we planned to eat left overs for breakfast next morning since we had to leave early. Our order took fairly long, but he was honest about the wait time.
  
  The food was delicious! The pizza sizes they offer are huge! 36" huge! Everything was flavorful.
  
  My favorite was the soup! It had bacon (YUMMY!).
  The pizza was sooo good. It had all types of meat (carnivore, duh). I liked that they let me add olives to it.
  
  I would totally recommend this place! Enjoy the food via the pics :)

• Rob C.

  star star star star star 17 August 2026

  This is our second time eating here in two years.  This time we ordered the salmon burger, carnivore pizza, the Cattleman, Mediterranean pizza, and the pulled pork wrap.  Everything was delicious.  The service was great, and the restaurant is very clean.  Not a single complaint about the food...we will be back.

• Margaret N.

  star star star star star 15 August 2026

  This restaurant is still as good as when I posted my first review. This owners certainly have done well converting this bus barn.
  The place was hopping since it's the middle of summer, of course. But the staff is friendly as ever and the food was excellent. So good, we went back a second day. While the pizza is a staple, the salads are very good and the cheesy breadsticks are delightful. The garlic and marinara dipping sauce really made the meal. My dining partners really enjoyed the Red Knot Scottish Ale. Good thing we had a designated driver in our bunch as they enjoyed it very much! You can expect a wait, but it was never more than 20 minutes.